Panama will ‘formally object to’ COP31 outcome – without oil cap, finance, ‘renewable’ electrification

In a highly unusual move, Panama has sent a letter to the COP31 presidencies declaring that it will block any outcome that does not meet its eight demands, including “a cap on oil production”.

The nation’s outspoken environment minister, Juan Carlos Navarro, has set out the nation’s position, the day after making headlines for declaring that COP31 is being held hostage by a “petroleum mafia”.

The letter – whose authenticity has been confirmed by Carbon Brief – states: “I inform you that Panama will not join any consensus, and will formally object in the closing plenaries, to the adoption of any decision that does not lead to an outcome satisfactory to our principles and our values.”

Panama’s demands can be paraphrased as follows:

  • Every decision must be based on the “best available science” and follow IPCC findings.

  • Text must acknowledge “failure of 1.5C” target and parties must report on what they are doing to close the gap between the current trajectory and 1.5C.

  • Move to adopting decisions by simple majority at UN climate talks, when consensus is not possible.

  • Negotiations under climate, biodiversity and desertification Rio conventions must be “joint and together”, to aid participation by small countries.

  • “Global oil production must be capped at current levels.”

  • “Developed countries, oil-producing countries and carbon emitters” must provide climate finance.

  • Prioritise action to protect biodiversity, forests, rivers, mangroves and the ocean.

  • An immediate push for electrification “based on renewable energy”.

As one of the few “carbon-negative” countries, Panama claims the “moral authority” to take these positions.

Alongside COP31 joint presidents Murat Kurum and Chris Bowen, the letter has been sent to UN Climate Change chief Simon Stiell and AILAC, the group of Latin American nations that Panama negotiates with.

It is safe to say that the new draft cover decision, which landed this afternoon at COP31, does not meet all of Panama’s demands. It remains to be seen how the small nation’s intervention will change things in the coming days.

Access the full letter here.